In the realm of family law, the plight of fathers is often misunderstood, underestimated, and sometimes even ignored, with many laughing at the plight of fathers, claiming that the family law courtroom is a level playing field. To shed light on the intricacies of fathers' rights and the challenges men face in family court, we turn to Samera Habib, a prominent family law attorney and partner at The Dadvocates P.C.
Samera Habib is not your average family law attorney. Licensed and practicing in both California and Colorado, her expertise encompasses child welfare, custody disputes, property settlements, and even criminal defense matters related to domestic violence, sexual assault, and child abuse. Her reputation precedes her, with numerous accolades such as Super Lawyers, Top Ten Best Female Attorneys, and Top Family Lawyers under her belt.
What sets Samera apart is her unparalleled dedication to championing fathers' rights, with a particular emphasis on ensuring that children have access to both parents. With a laser focus on cases involving alienation, domestic violence, coercive control, and cultural complexities, Samera's vast experience makes her an advocate like no other, and her commitment is not just limited to the courtroom. She invests intensely in getting to know each client while also preparing for every case. This ensures she knows all the fine details and that the attorney/ client relationship is on solid footing. This focus has frequently drawn commendations from judges and peers, with many clients expressing gratitude for her help.
The story of The Dadvocates P.C. is as unique as its founder. The firm emerged from Samera's background, compounded by her personal ordeal during her tumultuous divorce in 2010. As a child, her teachers described her as quiet and shy. However, she oddly tended to become outspoken if she witnessed injustice of any kind. As a teenager and young adult, Samera was a civil rights activist and fought for the underdog. A formative experience for Samera was witnessing her mother’s struggles as a parent after Samera’s father passed, struggling to both work and be there for her children. Despite her mother being remarkable and dedicated, Samera noted that children who had involved fathers had societal advantages and emotional stability that those whose fathers were not present lacked.
Later, during her divorce, Samera struggled to uphold her reputation as a dedicated mother in the face of false allegations, leading her to understand that a parent has no way of preventing embroilment in the devastating family law system. Samera quickly realized that due to her position as the mother, successfully disproving the false allegations made her eligible for 50% custody. However, she noted a pattern where fathers involved in family law court were routinely forced to prove that they could care for their children as little as every other weekend.
Samera realized that countless men and fathers face such biased prejudices daily in family court, with their starting point for custody being no more than every other weekend, a completely devastating reduction in parental access to their children. It shocked Samera that children could spend most of their time in school or daycare, no questions asked, but time extended time with their fathers is deemed somehow traumatic. Recognizing the injustice of this phenomenon, Samera became a beacon of hope for such men, ensuring they felt heard and represented, and she’s currently working to establish funding for litigant fathers who can’t afford to pay routine attorney fees.
In essence, The Dadvocates P.C. became a platform that emphasizes the importance of fathers in their children's lives. The firm's core mission transcends business objectives. As Samera aptly puts it, The Dadvocates is a grassroots movement aiming to “overhaul the presently flawed family law litigation system.”
The law clearly states that gender cannot be a determinant in custody decisions. However, the real-world scenario tells a different story, despite what opponents of the fathers’ rights movement have to say. Men often find themselves battling age-old stereotypes, gender-based biases, and unjust expectations. There can never be a level playing field when each parent is placed at a different starting point.
Despite legal protections, many fathers are still subjected to biased custody and child support agreements because they are starting off with much less than mothers. Outdated gender roles and unfounded allegations can significantly impact a father's capability to secure a fair deal; this is where an experienced attorney like Samera, armed with in-depth knowledge of the intricacies of such cases, becomes indispensable.
Historically, family law often favored mothers, especially when it came to child custody due to laws like the Tender Years Doctrine, which forced courts to presume that children of tender years need to be with their mothers. Traditionally, the law and society held that mothers were the primary caregivers and, therefore, better equipped to cater to the child's needs post-divorce. As a result, fathers frequently found themselves on the periphery of their children’s lives, limited to the role of the weekend parent or, worse, merely a financial contributor.
Although such doctrines have been abolished from the law, there have been few laws passed to counteract the damage that such legal doctrines have created in courts. It is a fatal fallacy to presume that the repeal of such laws has somehow made mothers and fathers equal in family court. In addition to parents, fathers who have supported a stay-at-home wife, especially for ten years or more, face crushing financial orders, frequently being ordered to pay more than their net income in support. In these situations, arguing that the father or husband will not have enough income to pay his bills falls on deaf ears, with courts failing to consider how detrimental this situation is to the family. Although it is shocking, when determining spousal support, the court must consider the lifestyle that the recipient spouse enjoyed during the marriage, but there is no requirement for suggesting the court consider what means the payor spouse will have to live well at all. These orders last many years, often a decade or more, and are crushing to the husband’s ability to recover from divorce and secure his future, including retirement.
"While the law may be clear in its wording, the interpretation and implementation often bear the weight of societal biases, with critical aspects determined by areas where the law remains oddly silent,” says Samera. “Fathers are not merely providers; they are an integral part of a child's emotional and psychological development. It's high time we shift our gaze from antiquated beliefs and recognize the equal importance of both parents in a child's life. Our legal systems should reflect this understanding and not perpetuate outdated norms.”
Over the years, there has been a significant shift in understanding the importance of both parents in a child's life. The shared parenting movement emphasizes that children benefit from a strong relationship with both parents. Numerous studies show that kids with involved fathers demonstrate better cognitive abilities, emotional health, and social outcomes. This movement paved the way for a more balanced approach in family law, promoting the best interests of the child by considering active involvement from both parents. Even what fathers are given that opportunity, the weight of crushing financial orders divest them of the time and means necessary to parent their children comfortably.
While legal shifts are ongoing, many fathers still grapple with:
Some fathers feel that they are automatically perceived as less competent caregivers simply because of their gender at the inception of custody disputes.
Fathers are frequently saddled with disproportional financial responsibilities, including child support and alimony, sometimes to the point of financial strain or insolvency, with no legal protection for their ability to support themselves or their children.
Even when fathers are granted visitation rights or shared custody, enforcing these arrangements can be an uphill battle, especially if the mother is uncooperative, with little to no consequences for mothers who violate custody orders, with courts arguing and ruling that they cannot issue orders to punish a parent, but rather, must only do what is in the best interests of the child. This, unfortunately, most often results in the court’s unwillingness to divest mothers who wrongfully withhold children of physical or legal custody. In lay terms, when a mother lodges false allegations or wrongfully withholds children, courts always err on the side of caution by restricting the father’s parental access to keep children safe. This effectively makes the mother the de facto primary parent, with the courts ultimately rewarding that mother’s wrongful and malicious conduct by giving her the lion’s share of physical and legal custody under the guise of the best interests of the child. All it takes is one allegation of abuse or violence, and this disgusting and vicious cycle is set in motion, with future increases in custody being nearly impossible to accomplish unless a monumental change in circumstances occurs. Once a father is divested of meaningful custody, the financial obligations to the other party to assist with the rearing of the children become crushing and unbearable.
It's essential to recognize the emotional and psychological toll these challenges can take on fathers. The battle for rights often leads to feelings of alienation, depression, and a deep sense of injustice. Fathers’ rights groups aim to provide support, both legal and emotional, to fathers going through these struggles.
While the U.S. has seen advances in the realm of fathers' rights, this is a global issue. Many countries are grappling with how to ensure fairness in family law. International cases, especially those involving child custody across borders, further highlight the complexities and the importance of robust legal mechanisms to protect fathers' rights.
The journey to achieving equality in family courts is ongoing. As more people become informed and engage in the conversation, there's hope for a more balanced future where fathers are valued not only for their economic contributions but also for their irreplaceable roles as caregivers, mentors, and protectors in their children's lives. The fight for fathers' rights is not just about legal battles; it is mainly about reshaping societal perceptions and norms so that both parents are at the same starting point.
Men often face unfavorable prejudices when it comes to spousal support or alimony. Although alimony is intended to balance economic disparities between spouses post-divorce, these settlements must be unbiased and just. The Dadvocates P.C., through its meticulous approach, strives to ensure that men receive fair alimony arrangements but are undoubtedly fighting against impossible laws.
"While many view the courtroom as the primary battleground for fathers' rights, the real change begins in the hearts and minds of society,” says Samera. “We must challenge and redefine outdated notions of what it means to be a father. Every case I take on is not just a legal endeavor but a step towards creating a world where a father's love, guidance, and presence are valued just as much as the financial support he can provide. Remember, our children watch and learn from us — let's show them a world where both parents stand on equal ground and are given the same opportunities to love and nurture their children."
The legal labyrinth of family law and fathers' rights can be daunting, especially with the staunch and unwavering opponents that the movement faces, namely, the domestic violence movement that paints almost all fathers as abusive and controlling. However, with experts like Samera and dedicated firms like The Dadvocates P.C., there's a renewed hope for fathers seeking justice. As they stand firm in their advocacy, they remind us of one fundamental truth: every child deserves a father, and every father who is willing and capable deserves the opportunity to parent their child.
About Samera Habib
Samera Habib's expertise in complex family law litigation has earned her numerous awards, including Super Lawyers Rising Stars and American Family Institute's 10 Best. Founder of The Dadvocates P.C., her practice is concentrated on fathers' and mens’ rights, including international custody disputes and property settlements. Her unique insights into cultural and gender complexities set her firm apart from others, who may be less cognizant of the important role that these intricate issues play.
Advertising disclosure: We may receive compensation for some of the links in our stories. Thank you for supporting LA Weekly and our advertisers.